Private versus Public Clouds

Michael Vizard

There's a war on over which of these two approaches will eventually come to dominate enterprise computing. Most of the arguments involve control and security versus costs. But when you get right down to the brass tacks, it's always going to come down to what it always does in every enterprise application debate: performance.

Providers of cloud computing services will argue that when it comes to performance, they have the inside track given their ability to build data centers using the latest and greatest IT infrastructure. The challenge facing the internal IT organization looking to build a private cloud is how to match those performance levels at an acceptable level of cost. Of course, many would argue there's more to it than that, but when you look at the ability to secure information in the cloud and the manageability tools becoming available, it's hard to say with absolute certainty that private clouds have an inherent advantage when it comes to security and manageability.

Of course, there's nothing magical about public cloud infrastructure, either. The companies that build public clouds leverage the same IT infrastructure as internal IT organizations, which is why you see vendors such as NetApp hosting events to market the same types of storage technologies to builders of both public and private clouds. Once upon a time, vendors sold service class and enterprise-class technologies, but those distinctions are becoming increasingly irrelevant as internal IT organizations morph into internal IT service providers.

The two real advantages that many public cloud providers have today are economies of scale in terms of acquiring equipment and highly disciplined IT procedures. The advantage an internal IT organization has is its ability to provide customized services and the simple fact that not every application workload needs blinding performance. More often than not, application workloads have varied levels of performance requirements, which means that a one-size fits all approach to cloud computing might not be the most economical way to go. Furthermore, internal IT organizations are getting better at running their operations like a business by the day.

Just about every IT industry professional, as evidenced by the attendees at this week's Cloud Computing Expo in New York, is equally divided about whether public or private cloud computing will win out, which is a sure sign that both models will probably thrive. The only real question is to what degree will each be used in connection with what types of application workloads. And despite the protestations of all the various cloud computing advocates, only time will really tell us the answer.

Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Oct 29, 2010 9:10 PM Luke Vorster Luke Vorster  says:
I think the Internet is a good model to take ideas from... i.e. how is it coping with public and private issues? In the previous 15-20 years, or so, it has been blatantly clear that the US internet industry has only proliferated the way it has due the convenience of inter-state law. When US companies want to deploy successful (in US/Canada) business vehicles in Europe, or other equally large domains, it becomes largely apparent just how inexperienced these companies are in _truly_ public cyber-environments. (I have been in projects where we had to bring in the big five just to help us knock out a temporary legal framework for inter-continental online business and taxation models) In the cases I have been invovled in, most systems required a complete re-analysis, and much money was spent on mentoring these companies in the ways of the rest of the world. I am not slagging the US here, I am just saying they have had it lucky for so long and didn't realise it until the late 90's... How is a public cloud different from a public search engine? How is a private cloud different from a national phone/sateliteTV/DVB broadcasting platform? Clouds are not a new concept at the political level. I have one positive point RE public clouds: TOTAL COST OF OWNERSHIP!!! Does anyone really want to bear the TOC of a private cloud? Haven't we learnt (over and over and over), that the long term issues invovlved in sustaining large scale computation resources can only be justified if the resources are seen as liabilities and the work done on them _extremely_ lucrative? Any comments welcome, as I am concerned about the future of the internet. Private clouds sounds like fragmentation in terms of technology and human demographics... Reply

Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.




Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.