Three Ways to Eliminate Annual Employee Reviews

Kachina Shaw
Slide Show

5 Tips to Retain Your Top IT Talent

We may yet see the death of the employee annual review in our lifetime. And it’s been a long time coming. This year, several very large corporations have announced that they will no longer put their managers and employees through the year-end torture. The shift appears to be taking hold fairly well in tech and tech consulting firms, perhaps as a result of the influence of workforces that skew somewhat younger than in other industries.

Let’s look at how companies are making this major change in order to benefit all employees and the bottom line.

Switch to a Focus on Coaching

Making news this week is Accenture’s rejection of the annual employee review in favor of ongoing performance assessments, in order to put a higher priority on the company’s 330,000 employees, says Chief Human Resources Officer Ellyn Shook in a Chief Learning Officer article. The plan is to put the focus on managerial coaching.

The shift will involve training for managers and learning/training executives in how to better “talk with” rather than “talk about” people. The increased feedback flowing back and forth, says Glint, Inc. CEO Jim Barnett, will require fast responses to keep employee engagement high. This is particularly of interest to millennials, according to many studies of their attitudes about what makes a good workplace.

Empower Your Managers

At Adobe, a switch from annual reviews to a monthly Check-In program includes broad latitude for managers to reward performance without interference from human resources. A post at outlines a long list of benefits the firm has enjoyed, including rewards for all qualifying employees (no forced rankings), huge time savings for managers, lower voluntary attrition and, of course, more open communication.


Take Advantage of Technology

At GE, where the dreaded forced ranking system got its start with CEO Jack Welch, management has decided that it is time for a change. That change, they say, might involve getting rid of performance ratings altogether. A pilot group is testing the method.

Meanwhile, more certain changes are planned that will harness the power of technology, according to the Washington Post. Managers and employees may start using apps to chart productivity and exchange frequent feedback, allowing more effective casual coaching. GE managers also cite time and money wasted on the annual review process, goals that are outdated and irrelevant by the time the end of the year arrives, and the possibility that technology could correct for human biases.

No matter the organizational goals, or the amount of time and money that could potentially be saved, acceptance that the annual review is a concept whose usefulness has expired appears to have taken root.

Kachina Shaw is managing editor for IT Business Edge and has been writing and editing about IT and the business for 15 years. She writes about IT careers, management, technology trends and managing risk. Follow Kachina on Twitter @Kachina and on Google+

Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Nov 29, 2015 8:43 PM Lauren Clarke Lauren Clarke  says:
I find quarterly reviews are really helpful in assisting the employees when it comes to work or even their personal growth. Enjoyed reading your post. Thank you! Reply

Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.



Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.