Conspiracy Theorists Unite! Intel Is out to Get You!

Don Tennant

There was an interesting piece on TheHill.com yesterday about Peter Cleveland, a lobbyist for Intel who's working hard to get Congress to pass immigration reform legislation that would make it easier for Intel and other companies to hire workers from India and China. I'm not a huge fan of lobbyists -- or Intel, for that matter. But there's more to this story than the conspiracy theorists would have us believe.


Here's an excerpt from that TheHill.com piece to give you an idea of where Cleveland's coming from and what he's trying to accomplish:

Intel says a shortage of qualified American engineers has forced the company, and others like it, to import qualified workers from India and China.


"We try to hire Americans first, but we can't find enough qualified Americans for high-level projects," Cleveland said. He noted that half the master's or Ph.D.-level engineering students enrolled at American universities are from other countries.


Intel wants Congress to make it easier for students to stay in the United States after graduating.


"We want to hire every Sriram Viswanathan [vice president of Intel's architecture group]. They create ideas and job base" in this country, Cleveland said.

I've been covering this topic long enough to know that there's a very vocal band of IT workers in this country who would argue that this story is just one more piece of evidence of a massive conspiracy being carried out by IT companies, the government, and the media. Their devilish aim: to promote cheap foreign labor at the expense of U.S. IT workers (not that people with advanced degrees from any country come all that cheaply, but let's not quibble).


What the conspiracy nuts would choose to ignore in condemning Intel in particular for its role in the evil scheme is that Intel is one of many technology companies that are working feverishly to promote education in the STEM disciplines in this country so that we don't have to rely so heavily on foreign talent.


Just last week, President Obama announced the formation of Change the Equation, a network of over 100 CEOs that, according to the organization's website, "pledges to create widespread literacy in science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) as an investment in our nation that empowers us all." This is how the organization explains its goals:


  • Great Teaching. Improve STEM teaching at all grade levels, with a larger and more diverse cadre of highly capable and inspirational STEM teachers.
  • Inspired Learners. Inspire student appreciation and excitement for STEM programs and careers to increase success and achievement in school and opportunities for a collegiate education, especially among females and students of color.
  • A Committed Nation. Achieve a sustained commitment to improving STEM education from business leaders, government officials, STEM educators and other stakeholders through innovation, communication, collaboration and data-based decision making.


Now, before we condemn Intel for its lobbying efforts to make it easier to hire foreign workers, let's consider what it's doing to change things so that it doesn't have to lobby for that particular cause. Let's open our eyes to the fact that Intel is a founding member of Change the Equation, and that Craig Barrett, the retired chairman and CEO of Intel, is chairman of the Change the Equation board.


So hey, wait a minute. Maybe it is a conspiracy: a conspiracy to overcome the obstacle of disenchanted parents dissuading their children from pursuing STEM careers. Those dirty dogs.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.


Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Sep 22, 2010 6:00 PM Matt Sweeney Matt Sweeney  says:

Don continues to be a voice of reason in the B to B media world.  Insightful, thoughtful and always worth the read.  I have missed his voice from the pages of Computerworld...

Sep 23, 2010 2:11 PM mataj mataj  says:

Increasing shareholder added value is not a conspiracy.

There is no shortage of qualified engineers. There's just a shortage of money for their wages.

Sep 24, 2010 8:50 AM Greer Trice Greer Trice  says: in response to mataj

That is a concise and precise factual statement.

Sep 24, 2010 11:27 AM mataj mataj  says: in response to Greer Trice

Thanxx. Oh, and maybe... well... I'm not quite sure it's worth it, but maybe I should respond to mr.Tennant's concluding remark about "dirty dogs" after all.

Disenchanted parents dissuading their children from pursuing STEM careers are not the cause of any problem, and certainly not a conspiracy. They are just a humble consequence of mighty market forces at work. The fact of the matter is, that STEM career's R.O.I. is pitifully low, and deep below zero for those poor bastards, who fell into the student loan trap


May 14, 2015 12:15 AM techzilla techzilla  says:
Jump for stem jobs? Your kidding right? Have you seen our wages? They wan't to lower the price of labor, it's not a conspiracy it's just a fact of business. The only conspiracy is the media's refusal to admit we don't actually have any scarcity. When the elitists want to explain why all our jobs were sent offshore, it wasn't a conspiracy, but market forces responding to a new globalist reality. The same market forces that bought the trade deals they lobbied for, but hey that's getting "conspiratorial". Why is it every time the market want's to buy politics it's a conspiracy? prices are not a conspiracy, the market applies to our political leaders.. who like all american's are merely a commodity. Reply

Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.




Subscribe Daily Edge Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Daily Edge Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.