Definition of Cyber War Remains Elusive, Even for Security Experts

Sue Marquette Poremba
Slide Show

Top 10 Cyber Security Threats of 2011 and Beyond

The next decade portends new threats that surpass those of years past in both intensity and impact.

"Cyber war" is a term that gets tossed around a lot these days. With every new style of attack, someone will predict that we have entered into cyber war and all sorts of experts will try to figure out what that means, exactly.


Cyber war was the main topic at the Kaspersky Lab Cyber Conference, to which I was lucky enough to be invited. The conference, called "2012: IT Security in the Age of Cyber Warfare," has covered a number of issues concerning when the first strike might have occurred - while many believe that it came in 2007 when Estonia was the victim of a massive cyber attack from Russia, not everyone attending this conference seemed convinced the attack constituted "war." It also covered how we should approach the international problem of cyber threats, and whether or not there is a true definition to the term "cyber war."


The question of what is cyber war was brought up during a panel discussion that included Eugene Kaspersky, CEO of Kaspersky Lab; Michael Moran, assistant director of cybersecurity and crime with Interpol; Alexander Ntoko, head, corporate strategy division, International Telecommunication Union; and Alexander Seger, secretary of the cybercrime convention committee, head of data protection and cybercrime division, Council of Europe. An impressive panel, to be sure.


Of course, there was no definitive answer on what constitutes a cyber war, just the educated and thoughtful opinions of four men well-versed in studying cyber crime who raised even more questions on how to define cyber war by the end of the conversation. There was agreement that we tend to get too caught up in semantics. As Moran said, words are easy to throw but definitions are hard to come by.


Do we even really need a definition? Will putting a label on a cyber attack make it any less or more destructive? I couldn't help but think of one of my favorite TV shows during this panel discussion, "M*A*S*H." In that show about the Korean War, viewers are often reminded that the military action in Korea was never actually called a war. It was called a "police action." But as the show's doctors and nurses often wondered, what was the difference between a war and a police action, because the results were pretty much the same.


So, perhaps cyber war is one nation purposely attacking another. Perhaps it is a nation retaliating against an attack. Maybe it is hacktivism or maybe it is when government leaders come together to squelch an uprising.


Whatever cyber war is, the panelists agreed on one important point: It will take a global effort to defend and prevent cyber threats. But that is not an easy task, either. Look for more discussion on that topic in the coming days.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.


Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Feb 9, 2012 10:00 AM John Forte John Forte  says:

You make a great point in this post. The issue shouldn't be what we name the issue; it should be what we are doing to be proactive and reactive to the consequences and effects of it. I look forward to reading your other posts on Cyber War.

Feb 9, 2012 10:03 AM random news random news  says:

One thing is definite; the Geneva Convention is outdated. I never realized the severity of a DDOS attack till I experienced it. It lasted over 48 hours, we were able to get the servers back up after 3 hours but there was a large loss of revenue. If the Pentagon were under such an attack I would think of it as an attack on sovereignty.


Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.




Subscribe Daily Edge Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Daily Edge Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.