TomTom and Microsoft Settle: Now Back to the Real World

Rob Enderle

After all the gnashing of teeth and war-like posturing by TomTom and FLOSS, TomTom and Microsoft settled when TomTom agreed to license the technology under dispute. Let's talk about what this means for FLOSS, TomTom and Microsoft.

FLOSS: In Search of a War


FLOSS, at least some of the more visible parts of it, seems to be in search of a war. Throughout this drama, there were statements that suggested people needed to rise up against Microsoft by blowing what was a small license dispute out of proportion. But, given the current economic environment, these efforts seemed to largely stay buried in the technology press, and even there seemed to lack much momentum. It had the feeling of a bunch of folks living in the past, trying desperately to open old wounds, in an atmosphere where the audience was vastly more concerned with other things.


In the end, with TomTom settling so easily, FLOSS is left looking like the boy who cried wolf and will have more difficulty getting much interest for this kind of thing in the future.


FLOSS desperately needs a purpose that is beyond being anti-Microsoft and desperately needs to focus its supporters on a cohesive set of goals they can get behind. GPL 3 split the base, and that means they have internal problems that make the group's ability to identify, let alone focus on, external threats less than ideal.


This is a wakeup call for FLOSS. While open source is clearly around to stay, currently the momentum and direction is moving to the large companies like Intel, IBM and HP, which are making the most money off of it. The old community is bleeding influence like a stuck pig.




TomTom appears to have long-term issues with IP, first with FLOSS and then with Microsoft. The fact that it was able to get a bunch of FLOSS folks to get excited in what, in hindsight, appears to be just an effort to improve their own negotiating position with Microsoft should give us a sense for where that company's priorities were. Clearly those priorities had nothing to do with open source software. Like most companies, it came down to the bottom line.


While the terms of the agreement are confidential, the fact that this was creating bad press for Microsoft during a time when it was under scrutiny by the European Union would have been hard to ignore during the negotiations. This likely did shift the balance to TomTom somewhat and put FLOSS in the position of patsy.


I doubt that will sit well with either Microsoft or FLOSS long term, and for a company that is trying to survive making lots of enemies over what should have been a minor agreement, that's not a good sign. In fact, it really has a very tactical feel to it. I expect the behavior likely worried lenders, investors and customers to a significant degree as well, easily overwhelming whatever negotiation benefits were achieved.


In short, while tactically sound given the outcome, strategically it was very foolish and likely made it more certain, rather than less, that the company would not recover from its current financial crisis.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.


Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Mar 31, 2009 8:06 AM Anonymous Insider Anonymous Insider  says:

FLOSS and its non-pacifist agenda...

While there's a distance in between open-source and free software in regard to quality (I'll post later quotes by Raymond and Stallman) both movements share a goal: non-pacificist agendas.

Here is a quote from Stallman from 1989: "I agree that my stubborn refusal to cooperate with a project, such as porting GCC to AU/X, is a form of hostilities.  If I treated innocent people that way, it would be wrong.  However, treating aggressors this way is justified and necessary.  I am not a pacifist."

See http://www.krsaborio.net/research/1980s/89/890602_a.htm

For more on free software and Stallman see http://www.krsaborio.net/research/unix/gnu.htm


Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.




Subscribe Daily Edge Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Daily Edge Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.