Emerging Challenge: Integrating Multiple SOAs

Loraine Lawson

Service-oriented architecture - the architecture approach you adopt to simplify integration and get everyone on the same page of standards -- that very same architecture is now causing integration problems.

In retrospect, it was inevitable. Haven't they told us from the start that you should build your SOA to match your business needs? Except businesses change -- they get bought out by bigger businesses, or they operate independently within huge, multinational conglomerates that one day decide the individual divisions should share more information. The business world is just too complex and dynamic a place for this not to become an issue.

Fortunately, this problem is not insurmountable. In fact, the answer's straightforward, though I wonder if the implementation would be. More on that in a moment.

You can learn more about this issue by watching "Multiple ESBs: SOA Reality in a Federated Environment," a Webcast featuring Gartner VP and Distinquished Analyst Masssimo Pezzi and Hub Vandervoort, the CTO for Progress Software. Progress sells application infrastructure software, including event-processing tools and SOA technologies, such as ESBs.

I'm not 100 percent sure how old this Webcast is, but it apparently aired fairly recently, since the Progress blog, The SOA Infrastructure, just posted a link to it on Friday, Jan. 25.

Pezzi provides the background on the three causes of this problem, which is called federated SOA. Sometimes, there is a pure technology cause -- one business unit might have its SOA based on SAP or Oracle and another unit might be more pure Microsoft, and so used that approach. Sometimes it's because there are actually different business requirements within a large organization: One department is on a limited budget and needs a simple SOA, while another focuses more on scalability or performance.

The result is that you have two or more SOAs, built slightly differently, with integration problems.

You could approach the problem by dismantling some of the SOAs and rebuilding, but as Pezzi describes it, that's a fool's game (my words, not his). He calls this approach expensive and risky.

A more realistic approach is to get the SOAs to work together. To do that, he says you'll have to tackle three fundamental challenges:

  1. Organizational. There's the least amount of discussion on this topic. Gartner recommends those doing SOA deployments create a SOA Center of Excellence. So, these centers of excellence will have to work through best practices together.
  2. Governance. This is a hard issue, according to Pezzi. You've somehow got to create an overarching set of governance rules for all the little SOA governances. Security should top the list of governance issues you'll need to resolve, according to Vandervoort.
  3. Technical. You've got to make all the enterprise service buses (ESB) work together so applications can access the services and the end points that belong to the other SOA domains, he says.

One way to do this is to agree to the standards and protocols each ESB must use and basically, through a registry, outline the rules the ESBs must obey. Another way, as Vandervoort explains, is to use another ESB to integrate all the ESBs. I like to think of it as a sort of Lord of the ESBs -- you know, one ESB to rule them all, find them, bring them all and in the darkness bind them. Coincidentally -- ahem -- Progress offers such a solution, called Sonic ESB.


This issue of multiple ESBs is not insubstantial. As I've written before, since most packaged solutions come with an ESB, you may have more of these sitting around than you think. Fortunately, as Robin Bloor, a partner with consultants Hurwitz & Associates, has pointed out, ESBs are really good at integration. Bloor went so far as to argue that, in fact, ESBs are essentially integration engines, pointing out even in November of last year that this meant they could be used to mediate between different SOAs.


(For fascinating historical information on ESBs, I recommend this piece by Paul Fremantle, co-founder and vice president of technical sales at WSO2.)


There's a lot of information in this nearly 25 minute-long presentation. You'll need to provide basic registration information -- your contact info, title, and a bit on your technology needs.


If you're short on time, just click on the "transcription" tab at the bottom of the presentation and then press pause on the video so you can read through it. But be forewarned -- there are a lot of cuts in Vandervoort's presentation, which aren't obvious when you read through the presentation. It can be a bit confusing.

More from Our Network
Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Jan 29, 2008 8:30 AM Rajeev Rajeev  says:
Any implementation even simple ones runs into rough weather, but the key to executional success is problem solving and forward thinking.http://tekno-world.blogspot.com Reply
Jan 29, 2008 12:21 PM Francis Carden Francis Carden  says:
D�j vu springs to mind here... Inrtegration is here to stay :)Speaking to a group the other day, I was surprised (or was I) at the number of nodding heads of agreement from an audience when I suggested that web service integration is a real issue. Simple reuse of services is just like any other application "re-use" and just like any other "integration" problem. What I mean is, build a web service, consume it for a while and then someone suggests a change to it. Not likely is the general response and so it's copied and modified. Sound familiar?Now it's not that black and white because you can build thousands of little services that should rarely need changing but evenutally someone has to consume all of those services, and manage them and test them.. and then build a solution which in itself, will need integrating.I am a big fan of SOA and am glad though, these kind of stories tell SOA as it is and not the panecea some think.Integration, any easier ? I don't think so but I still think SOA is the right approach because the alternative is unstrcutured Reply

Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.



Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.