Job Boards: So Last Year?

Susan Hall

Stop throwing good money after bad was one piece of recruiting advice for companies offered by Jim Milton, director of product marketing for SelectMinds, which produces talent acquisition and social recruiting software, when I interviewed him recently.


If you're posting jobs in the same places, but making fewer hires there, you've got to step back and reassess, he told me. Of course, his company's software makes it easier for employees to match internal jobs with folks they know from their social networks and he certainly wants to promote referrals.


But for job seekers and employers alike, a piece in The Wall Street Journal highlights just how inefficient the big job boards can be. It reported earlier on a Corporate Executive Board survey that found that 80 percent of companies plan to use alternatives to the major job boards this year.


Based on an analysis of hiring data, Jobs2web found companies look through about:


  • 219 applications per job from those responding to a post on a major board, such as Monster or CareerBuilder
  • 116 applicants from social-media sites such as Facebook and LinkedIn
  • 33 from job hunters who find the post on the company's own career site
  • 32 per hire when job seekers type the position they are looking for into a search engine


Jobs2web analyzed 1.3 million applications and 26,000 hires in 2010.


The article doesn't break out niche job sites, though the number of them has doubled since 2000, according to Workforce Management. It quotes consultant Peter Weddle saying:

When it comes to finding a job, even social-network aficionados know to go to the job site with the most impact.

A January study by consultancy CareerXroads found that half of all openings are filled internally. And the report added:

Reports of job boards' death are, perhaps, premature.

It put hiring from referrals at 27.5 percent, job boards at 24.9 percent, company career sites at 18.8 percent and college recruitment at 18.8 percent.

Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Dec 19, 2011 11:35 AM Neil Kirchoff Neil Kirchoff  says:

I would have to agree with Jim Milton because some known researchers made a study on this thing recently. The job market has started to evolve in ways most of people never expected. I heard of one of those payroll outsourcing companies that was hiring people like you said in your article; Via the social circles of the employees. I was approached by someone the same way with a very good job and of course I said yes.


Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.



Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.