Newsletters Welcome, Guest Log In | Register

Microsoft News and Notes

Observations about Microsoft, the world’s largest software vendor

About this Blogger RSS

Subscribe

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.

  • Daily Edge
  • CTO Edge Update
  • Business Tools & Templates
  • Aligning IT & Business Goals
  • Maximizing IT Investments

2

Microsoft vs. Google? Not Really, in This Case

Posted by Kachina Shaw Oct 16, 2008 1:58:35 PM

As I wrote yesterday, some folks think it's within the realm of possibility that Microsoft will offer its Office suite over the Internet. A bit of news today is used by some to illustrate that Redmond better get busy on that. Computerworld's Preston Gralla writes that Washington, D.C.'s decision to use Google Apps instead of Microsoft Office to produce some content for an ongoing intranet project is "trouble." Others will follow where D.C. leads, he predicts.

 

The savings reported by CTO Vivek Kundra, who is leading the intranet build-out, does sound hefty: $475,000 per year vs. $4 million. However, the comparison involves proprietary software from Plumtree, not Microsoft. It can also be easy to miss that the city's entire workforce isn't switching from Microsoft to Google desktop applications, nor is every function within the intranet. (Kundra does offer some interesting ideas about letting the two desktop suites battle it out on city employees' desks.) Kundra touts the attractiveness of Google Apps' open standards, but the example of putting YouTube videos of managers describing job openings onto a job fair site kind of makes me hope that was a little joke.

 

Also yesterday and today, a massive Gmail outage is affecting an unknown number of customers, some of whom are reporting that they cannot conduct business as usual, reports IDG.

 

Clearly, one intranet project does not a crisis make for Microsoft, at least not in this case. The multiple outages that Google Apps users, including paying customers using the Premier tool set, have been experiencing this week and throughout the year cannot be ignored by enterprises evaluating the viability of Google's tools in mission-critical environments.

Add a comment Leave a comment on this blog post.
Oct 17, 2008 11:23 AM Guest jack  says:

"The multiple outages that Google Apps users....this week and throughout the year cannot be ignored by enterprises evaluating the viability of Googles tools in mission-critical environments."

 

Ordinarily that statement might be valid.  But when Google apps' early versions are compared with those of Microsoft....well, need I say more.

Oct 30, 2008 11:13 AM Guest bean  says:

Do you mean to say, you are ok with using faulty apps from Google just because they are new on the block?

A Dynamic Solution to Processing Paper

Discover a document management system that preserves company profits by reducing the overhead of paper invoices, utilizing employee time effectively, and significantly reducing collection cycle times.

Laptop Security

Answers to the ongoing challenges of the mobile office: to work anywhere, securely and efficiently.

Data Warehousing for Business Intelligence

Comprehensive storage solutions for better data access and retrieval, leading to better-informed business decisions.

Data Loss Protection

Data-loss prevention tactics, technologies and best practices to protect your sensitive and valuable company data.

Energy Efficiency

Best practices to optimize computing ability while minimizing power costs.

Social Media Policies Toolkit

Define the rules at your company for the proper use of social media platforms such as Blogs, Twitter, Facebook and Youtube. Ensure your users are spending their time productively and company resources are being used for the business.

Learn more >

Strategic IT Planning & Governance Best Practices Guide

Use this guide — along with the more than 60 templates included — to ensure the overall success of your entire IT department.

Learn more >