Beyond PUE: The Bigger Picture of Data Center Efficiency

Arthur Cole

Lowering your data center's power consumption will certainly help you cut your operating expenses, but is it necessarily the most efficient use of enterprise resources?


That's a key question as the industry heads into greener pastures, driven both by high energy costs and no small amount of government prodding.


The problem is that lowering your energy consumption is only half the equation when it comes to evaluating overall efficiency. The other half is productivity. The most energy-efficient data center in the world would be one that sits idle, and yet it would be completely inefficient because it is not getting any work done.


This has been a big bone of contention between some energy-usage experts and the federal government. Under the EPA's Energy Star program (It's almost like third grade, isn't it? Do well in class and get a star!), the Power Usage Effectiveness rating plays the dominant role in gauging star-worthiness. The problem is, PUE only measures the amount of energy being used for actual computer work, as opposed to ancillary functions like cooling and running the microwave in the break room.


Fortunately, The Green Grid, which originally devised the PUE benchmark, is already working on a more inclusive measurement: the Data Center energy Productivity (DCeP) metric. Simply put, it's a measurement of the amount of actual work being produced per unit of energy consumed. Ideally, this measurement should include all energy consumption -- servers, storage, cooling and, yes, the microwave. But as ZDnet's David Chernicoff points out, there doesn't seem to be much of a drive to establishing DCeP as an industry standard.


That leaves the PUE as the only game in town. And to be fair, the measurement does foster a culture bent more on supplying energy to computing resources than cooling. Google, for one, has been highly successful at lowering its PUE across its substantial data center infrastructure through such simple approaches as hot aisle containment, resource consolidation and the deployment of power-saving systems. The company strives for a PUE rating of 1.5 or less, when a 2 rating means you devote equal energy to both computing and non-computing activities.


The issue remains, however, that if simply lowering energy consumption reduces the amount of work a given data center can handle, then that workload has to be diverted somewhere else. And that somewhere else may or may not have the same efficiency rating as the primary facility.


On paper it looks good. But in the end, is anything being saved? And are carbon emissions any lower?



Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Jun 19, 2010 12:26 PM greg schulz greg schulz  says:

Thanks Art for the great and timely article as well as perspective about PUE.

This begs the question of are you measuring PUE, power usage, productivity or enterprise/IT Data Center effectiveness in terms of efficiency.

Most discussions I see and hear pertaining to PUE tend to focus on managing PUE or at best managing or comparing macro facility efficiency however do not take into consideration actual production or productivity effectiveness.

Thus PUE can be a handy macro metric, part of a broader set of gauges and measurements into how parts of the information factory are being run however it also needs to be put into context of the bigger picture. That bigger picture is how is the information factory (e.g. data center or cloud facility) actually performing in terms of work performed, information moved, processed, stored and accessed to gauge real energy effectiveness.

For those interested, here are some links to related topics, themes and items:

Saving Money with Green IT: Time to Invest In Information Factories

http://storageioblog.com/?p=767

PUE, Are you Managing Power, Energy or Productivity?

http://storageioblog.com/?p=711

Green IT, Green Gap, Tiered Energy and Green Myths

http://storageioblog.com/?p=1107

California Center for Sustainable Energy (CCSE)

http://storageioblog.com/?p=1073

Cheers gs

Greg Schulz-Author 'The Green and Virtual Data Center' (CRC)

Reply
Jun 23, 2010 5:11 AM Jack Pouchet Jack Pouchet  says:

Arthur,

You hit the nail on the head with regards to PUE- it is merely a power ratio and has nothing to do with data center productivity. A data center with a PUE of 3 can run circles around one with a PUE of 1.5 any day of the week. Further, the focus strictly on CO2 may be leading to poor business decisions on a productivity basis.

For a related discussion on ENERGY STAR, PUE, and Productivity see

http://www.emerson.com/edc/blog.aspx

Best regards.

Jack Pouchet

Director Energy Initiatives

Emerson Network Power

http://www.efficientdatacenters.com

Reply

Post a comment

 

 

 

 


(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.

 

null
null

 

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.