Outsourcing as Means to Achieve Innovation, but not an End

Ann All

Can outsourcing be about both cost reduction and business transformation? Maybe, but I am beginning to have my doubts.


Peter Allen, TPI's managing director for Global Practices, and Everest Research Institute VP Katrina Menzigian both told me in interviews that outsourcing clients now want benefits beyond labor arbitrage and take a more strategic view of outsourcing. Sudhakar Ram, chairman and managing director of Indian services provider Mastek Ltd., was quoted in a recent Wall Street Journal article as saying a "third wave" of outsourcing is coming, in which companies like his will begin designing systems and platforms for clients rather than simply following orders.



I'm not sure that's reflected in a recent Capgemini survey in which 60 percent of executives said outsourcing could make their businesses more agile and flexible. Seventy percent of executives also said they could save money by switching certain IT, finance, human resources, customer service or procurement processes to an outsourcing partner and then apply it toward growth initiatives.


It sounds to me like the respondents see outsourcing as a means to achieve innovation, rather than an end. Internal organizations become more agile when routine and labor-intensive tasks are offloaded, freeing staff for more strategic activities. Am I missing something? Maybe internal and external staffs work together on transformative tasks, but it doesn't sound that way.


Outsourcing for innovation also raises the specter of the management question. According to Gartner, many organizations still struggle to manage their outsourcing relationships, underestimating the amount of end-to-end effort required. If it's difficult to manage outsourcing initiatives based primarily on cost reduction, how much harder will it be for more strategic relationships?

Add Comment      Leave a comment on this blog post
Sep 11, 2009 11:20 AM Panagiotis Manousakos Panagiotis Manousakos  says:

You are spot on Ann.  I often say that expanded agility can someties lead to the irresistable temptation to lose focus. As someone who has coodinated a few outsource initiatives, I am of the mind that your view will come to be shared by many.

Sep 21, 2009 1:31 AM Outsourced Software Development Outsourced Software Development  says:

To forge ahead in strategic relationship without struggle may seem a bit difficult but not impossible, its only a beginning of evolution of new paradigms in Outsourcing.


Post a comment





(Maximum characters: 1200). You have 1200 characters left.




Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up now and get the best business technology insights direct to your inbox.